Skip to main content
Hero Image

Colorado’s Creative Professionals Are All Threatened by This Law

By Sarah Kramer posted on:
December 19, 2017

Graphic designer Lorie Smith has followed Colorado cake artist Jack Phillips’ case with concern for several years, watching it make its way through the court system all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

As a Christian creative professional who also lives in Colorado, she knows the outcome of Jack’s case could also impact her artistic and religious freedom. It’s what has kept her from expanding her business the past few years.

Last year, she decided to do more than wait and watch.

She filed a lawsuit against the state in 2016, challenging the law that has silenced her and stunted her business growth. Alliance Defending Freedom filed a brief with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit this week, after another court ruled earlier this year that she could not challenge the Colorado rule at the center of her – and Jack’s – case.

Lorie owns graphic design studio 303 Creative and specializes in creating and designing custom websites, which include customized text, graphics, images, and other content that promote ideas, events, or organizations. Owning her own business has allowed Lorie to take on the projects she feels passionate about and those that line up with her beliefs. In fact, she often does work for churches and religious organizations.

The past few years, though, Lorie has wanted to expand her business into the wedding industry. She wants to design custom wedding websites that proclaim and celebrate the beauty of marriage as God designed it – as the lifelong union between one man and one woman.

But a Colorado law is being interpreted to require Lorie to use her artistic talents to promote same-sex marriages if she promotes marriages between one man and one woman. The law even prohibits her from publicly explaining her religious beliefs about marriage on her website.

On top of that, violating the law means costly and burdensome investigations, fines of up to $500 for each violation, and oppressive mandates, like re-education training designed to compel Lorie to agree with Colorado’s views on marriage.

Lorie has watched as this law has been enforced against Jack. (Because Jack declined to use his artistic talents to design a custom cake celebrating a same-sex wedding, the State of Colorado demanded that he “re-educate” his staff at Masterpiece Cakeshop – mostly his family – on the definition of marriage.)

Because of this, Lorie has kept out of the wedding industry for fear that she would be punished. The result of this Colorado law has been to silence people who hold dissenting viewpoints on marriage.

This Colorado law is similar to many others across the country, and ADF is defending a number of creative professionals against such assaults on their freedom. ADF has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to uphold religious and artistic freedom by ruling in Jack’s favor, and we will continue to litigate on behalf of these artists. Securing these freedoms for them means securing them for us all.

Get the latest updates on Lorie’s case and others like it by signing up for our newsletter.
Keep Me Updated

Sarah Kramer

Sarah Kramer

Digital Content Specialist

Sarah worked as an investigative reporter before joining the Alliance Defending Freedom team.

Religious Freedom

The Equality Act Risks the Rights of Every American

What many supporters of the bill won't tell you is that if passed, the Equality Act would pave the way for dangerous policies which could undermine fairness and freedom.

Religious Freedom

This New Virginia Law Looks a Lot Like the Equality Act

The so-called Virginia Values Act is very similar to the proposed Equality Act. Except the Equality Act would go even further.

Religious Freedom

This Lawsuit Threatens the Rights of Faith-Based Schools to Operate According to Their Beliefs

If successful, college students would be forbidden from using their federal tuition assistance at schools that proclaim widely held religious teachings on marriage, gender, and sexuality.