Skip to main content
Supreme Court of the United States

Justice Thomas Issues Important Reminder About Religious Freedom

By Maureen Collins posted on:
October 7, 2020

This week, Justice Clarence Thomas reminded us of this important truth: People of faith should be able to live according to their beliefs without fear of government punishment.

This reminder came in Thomas’s concurrence to a denial for certiorari in a case called Davis v. Ermold. The case involved a county clerk in Kentucky, Kim Davis, who declined to issue a marriage certificate to a same-sex couple after the Obergefell v. Hodges decision nationalized same-sex marriage.

While Thomas didn’t think the questions of the case were clear enough to warrant the Court’s hearing, he did think that it brought up this important reminder for all Americans.

After the Obergefell decision, many were concerned that people of faith—such as Christians, Muslims, and Orthodox Jews—who believe that marriage is a union of one man and one woman would have their First Amendment rights compromised. Some brushed off this concern. But, as Justice Thomas notes, it turned out to be well warranted.

“Since Obergefell, parties have continually attempted to label people of good will as bigots merely for refusing to alter their religious beliefs in the wake of prevailing orthodoxy,” writes Thomas.

He then goes on to cite two Alliance Defending Freedom cases, in which we defended three clients whose religious beliefs about marriage almost prevented them from legally running their businesses. Each of these clients seek to live out their Christian beliefs in their everyday lives—including in their businesses. Unfortunately, government officials tried to stand in their way of doing this.

 

Jack Phillips of Masterpiece Cakeshop

Jack Phillips was punished by the Colorado Civil Rights Commission because he declined to create a custom wedding cake celebrating a same-sex marriage. Thankfully, the Supreme Court acknowledged that the Commission’s actions were unconstitutional in its landmark decision Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission.

 

Breanna Koski and Joanna Duka of Brush & Nib Studio

Similarly, Joanna and Breanna’s freedom to create handmade invitations and designs in their calligraphy business Brush & Nib Studio was almost compromised. A law in Phoenix would have required them to create artwork promoting events and messages that go against their Christian beliefs. Also like Jack, Breanna and Joanna won their case—the  Arizona Supreme Court recognized that Phoenix cannot force artists to express messages or celebrate events that violate their beliefs.

 

Contrary to what the culture says, Jack, Joanna, and Breanna want to live out their Christian beliefs through their work not because they want to force others to be like them. Rather, they want what’s best for everyone. Christians joyfully spread the Good News because they want to encourage others to live in a way that promotes individual flourishing.

The government officials in both these situations did the opposite. They wanted to force others to submit to their worldview or face grievous consequences.

This violates our Constitution.

But there is good news: More courts are upholding the right to religious freedom.

Earlier this week, a federal court ruled in favor of a Christian adoption provider. The provider, New Hope Family Services, is under threat from the state of New York simply because of its religious beliefs. Thankfully, this ruling ensures that New Hope can continue to operate while its lawsuit against the state proceeds.

As Justice Thomas’ concurrence argues, just because the government doesn’t like a person’s religious beliefs doesn’t mean they should be banished from the marketplace under the threat of punishment. Common decency—and our Constitution—demand the opposite.


Maureen Collins

Maureen Collins

Digital Cultivation Manager

Maureen Collins serves as the Digital Cultivation Manager at Alliance Defending Freedom.


Resolution 1
Senate Resolution Reminds Us Why Religious Education Should Be Celebrated

Earlier this week, Senator Lindsay Graham introduced Senate Resolution 407, legislation that celebrates religious schools and their contributions to our country by designating the first week of October as “Religious Education Week.”

Church
How Houston Pastors Successfully Stood Up for Their Constitutional Rights

Imagine if you had escaped government oppression in search of freedom and safety for your family in a new country—only to be greeted yet again with the government treading on Constitutional rights.

Lainey 1
West Virginia State Soccer Player Stands Up for Women’s Sports

When it comes to secondary and collegiate athletics, West Virginia’s save women’s sports law makes sure males who identify as female cannot take a spot on any team from a deserving girl.