Key Takeaways
- ADF filed a Title IX complaint with the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights on behalf of Maine high school juniors Reagan Wilson and Morgan Clark.
- Both Reagan and Morgan were forced to compete against a male athlete.
- Under Maine policy, any male who identifies as female can play on a girls’ team.
- This is unacceptable. Girls should never have their fairness and equal opportunity compromised by male athletes on the field.
Girls’ sports exist for a reason.
Separate teams give girls a fair chance to compete, to win, and to earn the rewards that come from years of hard work and sacrifice. Separate teams also give girls some much-needed privacy when it comes to locker rooms.
In Maine, right now, girls’ sports are compromised. State policy lets any male who identifies as female play on a girls’ team. The result is a stacked deck. Girls who have trained for years now face male athletes with inherent biological advantages, and the girls are the ones forced to pay the price.
That is why two high school juniors, Reagan Wilson and Morgan Clark, are asking the federal government to step in. With Alliance Defending Freedom, they have filed a Title IX complaint urging the U.S. Department of Education to require Maine to change course and restore a level playing field for girls across the state.
Meet Reagan and Morgan
Reagan Wilson and Morgan Clark have spent much of their lives on the field, and neither plans to stop. Both girls love the thrill of competition, as well as the hard work that goes into being an athlete.
Reagan Wilson
Reagan is a junior at Fryeburg Academy in Fryeburg, Maine, and a true multisport athlete.
“I’ve competed in swimming, cross country, indoor and outdoor track, soccer, and softball,” she said at a press conference.
Reagan earned “All Conference” honors in both cross country and softball and qualified for the state meet in both cross country and indoor track and field. Unfortunately, Reagan has also been forced to compete against male athletes. On the soccer field, Reagan has seen her team lose to a team with a male athlete. Reagan has also suffered the indignity of being displaced directly by a male athlete in cross country. This is obviously discouraging for Reagan—but it’s hardly surprising.
“Men are naturally stronger and faster than women due to the muscle growth that testosterone creates,” Reagan said. “Naturally, the men I competed against displaced several girls across different sports.
“This is unacceptable and has deprived me and so many other girls of equal opportunity to compete and win.”
Morgan Clark
Morgan is a junior at Windham High School in Windham, Maine, and captain of her school’s varsity girls’ soccer team.
“I’ve played soccer in Maine since I was four years old,” she said at the same press conference event.
Her team has long been one of the best in its region, and she intends to play in college. Morgan, like Reagan, has been forced to compete against a male athlete. And for Morgan, the impact that this male athlete had on her beloved sport was sudden, noticeable, and very real.
“Our [soccer] team is seeing the negative effects of male competitors,” Morgan explained. “In October, our team tied against a team we’ve easily outranked in past years, a team with a male athlete.”
Morgan added: “Last year, this sort of thing was something I only saw online, but now it’s something that I’m seeing in my own field.”
Both girls put in the time and the effort to be the best athletes they could possibly be. Yet, due to Maine’s lawmakers embracing gender ideology, all that time and effort meant little in the face of physically dominant male athletes. That’s why Reagan and Morgan are asking the federal government to finally make it a fair playing field again.
Maine’s policy violates federal law
Maine’s high school sports are governed by the Maine Principals’ Association (MPA), and its policy is simple: Any male who identifies as female may play on a girls’ team if he chooses. The policy sets no physical or hormonal requirements, and it bars schools from requiring medical records or official documents to establish a student’s gender identity.
The policy is backed up by state law. The Maine Human Rights Act makes it unlawful to exclude anyone from a school program because of gender identity, including women’s sports.
But both state law and school policy violate federal laws like Title IX. Sex-based categories in school athletics exist to give women and girls the opportunity for meaningful competition and a fair chance at victory. By allowing males to opt into female-designated teams, Maine is discriminating against women and girls, depriving them of fair and safe competition.
That’s why in April 2025, the U.S. Department of Education referred the Title IX investigation into the Maine Department of Education to the U.S. Department of Justice. Despite those actions, Maine has taken no steps to fix it.
The deck is stacked against girls
This fall, a male freshman who identifies as female joined the girls’ varsity soccer team at South Portland High School, and he has reshaped the program. In the first several weeks, he scored seven goals, including a hat trick (three goals in a game). In the past season, he scored or assisted on about half of the team’s goals.
The standings tell the rest of the story. The season before he joined, South Portland ranked 14th in its region. Now it ranks 2nd. And it’s the girls who are being forced to bear the cost. On Aug. 29, Reagan’s team lost to South Portland. On Oct. 1, Morgan’s team at Windham played South Portland to a tie, lowering Windham’s ranking. Both girls plan to play next year and expect to face the same male athlete again.
Unfortunately, Reagan has been here before. In 2024, she lost to a male cross-country runner who placed first at the Western Maine Championships. The next year, her team’s ranking suffered in indoor track and field after a male athlete placed first in the pole vault at the state championships. Those events are not part of this complaint, but they show that Maine knows the harm its policy causes and keeps it in place anyway.
What Reagan and Morgan are asking for
On Nov. 2, ADF filed a Title IX complaint with the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights (OCR) on behalf of Reagan and Morgan.
The argument is straightforward. Maine built a system of sex-designated sports, which Title IX allows. Then it layered an exception on top that lets males opt into the girls’ category. That deprives girls, because of their sex, of an equal opportunity to compete and win in their own sports—a violation of Title IX.
Given these violations, we’re asking the OCR to require the MPA and its member schools to eliminate the gender-identity exception and to remedy past violations. This comes after the Supreme Court’s June 2026 decision in West Virginia v. B.P.J., which reaffirmed that “sex” in Title IX means biological sex, not gender identity, particularly in the sports context.
“Many girls and women are discovering the crushing disappointment that comes from being beaten in their own sports by males who should have never been allowed to compete in the first place,” Reagan said.
Morgan put it even more simply: “If it can happen to me, it can happen to you.”
The bottom line
Every time a male athlete competes on a girls’ team, the athletic opportunities of deserving girls are destroyed. That violates Title IX—and Reagan and Morgan are asking the federal government to fix this.
Timeline
- February 2025: President Donald Trump signed Executive Order 14201, “Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports.” The Maine Principals’ Association says it will keep following state law on gender identity.
- April 2025: The U.S. Department of Justice sued the Maine Department of Education over its policy.
- June 2026: The U.S. Supreme Court decided West Virginia v. B.P.J., reaffirming that Title IX protects “sex,” not “gender identity.”
- November 2026: ADF filed a Title IX complaint with the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights on Reagan and Morgan’s behalf.



