BLOGThis Is What Happens When Universities Favor Certain Student Groups over Others

By Sarah Kramer Posted on: | May 18, 2017

Courts have ruled time and again that promoting some viewpoints while stifling others is unconstitutional. Yet, it seems California State University San Marcos hasn’t gotten the memo. 




Here’s the scoop: The Students for Life chapter at CSUSM wanted to bring Dr. Mike Adams to campus to speak on the issue of abortion. When the group applied for funding, however, they were told that student activity funding cannot be used to pay an honorarium or speaking fee for an outside speaker.

That was surprising to the pro-life student group, considering that, the Gender Equity Center and the LGBTQA Pride Center, which together receive more than $296,000 in student activity funding, regularly use those funds to bring in outside speakers.

Surely, there was some sort of mistake. The university couldn’t be playing favorites, right?

Wrong. It turns out the Gender Equity Center and the Pride Center receive over 22% of the student activity fee funding. With over 100 student groups on campus, that translates to roughly 2% of the student organizations on campus receiving over 22% of the student activity fee funding.

That just doesn’t add up.

You see, all students pay a mandatory Student Activity Fee when they attend CSUSM. Associated Students, Inc. (ASI) then allocates these funds to the student organizations on campus. Student groups apply to ASI to receive funding for their various activities and events on campus. 

Here’s where the problem lies: ASI does not have any guidelines or criteria to abide by when determining how to distribute these funds. So, certain student groups can easily be favored over others.

This unequal treatment is viewpoint discrimination—a blatant violation of the Constitution. Today, ADF filed suit on behalf of Students for Life at California State University San Marcos.

This is not the first case of university officials allowing the unequal allocation of student activity fees. Obviously, CSUSM did not take note when we filed a lawsuit on behalf of Students for Life at Colorado State University for a similar policy.

And they must have also missed the U.S. Supreme Court case Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System v. Southworth, where the court ruled 9-0 that public universities must allocate student fee funding in a viewpoint neutral fashion if they choose to make paying the fee mandatory.

Perhaps now CSUSM will pay a little more attention to the Constitution.


University Officials Cannot Pick and Choose Which Viewpoints to Promote and Which to Stifle

Alliance Defending Freedom is working to protect the First Amendment on public university campuses. And ADF’s Center for Academic Freedom is at the forefront of litigation defending these rights. To stay up to date on this case and other cases like it, sign up for our newsletter.

Keep Me Updated

Sarah Kramer

Digital Content Specialist

Sarah worked as an investigative reporter before joining the Alliance Defending Freedom team.

More from ADF View All

Can You Guess Why This New York Adoption Provider Is In Danger of Being Shut out of Adoptions?

Religious Freedom

Can You Guess Why This New York Adoption Provider Is In Danger of Being Shut out of Adoptions?

New Hope Family Services has been serving the community of Syracuse, New York...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 12/07/2018 21:49:15 Read More

This Brave Young Woman Is Making Her Voice Heard at the U.S. Supreme Court

Religious Freedom

This Brave Young Woman Is Making Her Voice Heard at the U.S. Supreme Court

School districts have a constitutional duty to uphold and protect the privacy...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 11/19/2018 20:28:19 Read More

WATCH: Career or Conscience? Why This Nursing Student Was Forced to Choose.

Sanctity of Life

WATCH: Career or Conscience? Why This Nursing Student Was Forced to Choose.

Anne-Marie's dream seemed closer than ever. Until she applied for the graduat...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 11/28/2018 22:01:48 Read More

2 Reasons Christian Students Should Attend Areté Academy – No Matter Their Career Path

Culture

2 Reasons Christian Students Should Attend Areté Academy – No Matter Their Career Path

As an accounting student, I wasn’t sure if I was a great fit for the Areté Ac...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 12/07/2018 16:33:31 Read More