Skip to main content
Supreme Court of the United States

Watch: Why David Benham and 3 Pastors Were Arrested Outside of an Abortion Clinic

By Maureen Collins posted on:
April 13, 2020

While abortion facilities in Charlotte, North Carolina, have been allowed to continue operating during the COVID-19 outbreak, pro-life groups have not been afforded the same opportunity.

On April 4, several members of the pro-life group Cities4Life were peacefully standing outside an abortion facility. Then the police arrived.

It didn’t matter that these pro-life witnesses were following all the guidelines put into place by North Carolina’s “stay-at-home” order—they only gathered in groups of less than 10 people and maintained a distance of six feet from others. It also didn’t matter that Cities4Life a non-profit organization, is an “essential service” and therefore permitted to stay active during the state’s lockdown.

The police still arrested several pro-life advocates for “violating” the stay-at-home order, including three pastors and David Benham, who is the president of Cities4Life.

You might have heard of the Benham Brothers: David and his twin brother Jason were in the news in 2014 after HGTV cancelled their upcoming home improvement show because of the brothers’ beliefs about marriage.

After a video of David’s exchange with a police officer was posted on the brother’s Twitter account, they are in the news yet again.




Senator Ted Cruz (R-TX) even retweeted the video, calling the arrests “unconstitutional.”

He’s right. No one should be arrested for demonstrating on a public sidewalk. This is a blatant violation of the First Amendment right to free speech.

That’s why Alliance Defending Freedom has sent a demand letter to the City of Charlotte on behalf of David Benham, Cities4Life, and Love Life volunteers.

While we all should be cognizant of guidelines like social distancing and other precautions to prevent the spread of the coronavirus, the government shouldn’t apply these guidelines unequally. Love Life is an essential business and was within its rights to gather while practicing social distancing.

On the other hand, it’s also troubling that abortion facilities are considered “essential businesses” by North Carolina and many other states. The abortion businesses shouldn’t be able to skirt social-distancing guidelines that other medical professionals must abide by, and use valuable medical supplies just so they can continue to profit during a national emergency. Especially not while pro-life witnesses are carted off to jail for peacefully praying and providing much needed material support for expectant mothers and fathers outside their doors.

As a nation, we should be banding together to protect the most vulnerable members of our society. Allowing abortion businesses to continue operations while arresting pro-life volunteers goes directly against this goal.

Maureen Collins

Maureen Collins

Digital Cultivation Manager

Maureen Collins serves as the Digital Cultivation Manager at Alliance Defending Freedom.

Fighting for free speech at the Supreme Court
Free Speech Is a Human Right

A nation’s freedom is measured partly by the amount of speech its government tolerates.

303 Lorie Smith at Supreme Court Religious Freedom
Can the Government Force You to Speak? This 10th Circuit Decision Says “Yes”

Working with ADF attorneys, Lorie Smith’s case currently awaits a decision by the U.S. Supreme Court, after a lower court ruled against her earlier this year.

Lorie Smith at Supreme Court Religious Freedom
Let Lorie Smith (Not) Speak!

It is long past due for creative professionals and artists such as Lorie to stop living under the threat of compelled speech and government coercion.