Skip to main content
Supreme Court of the United States

Church Autonomy: What It Is and Why It’s Important

By Scott Blakeman posted on:
June 16, 2021

A church or house of worship needs to maintain independence from government control in certain fundamental ways. This is vital not only for its thriving but also for the flourishing of religious freedom throughout the United States.

There is a legal term for this concept: church autonomy.

So, what exactly is church autonomy and why is it important? Let’s briefly explore the topic.

As we saw in the video, the Constitution helps protect churches and other houses of worship from unnecessary government interference so that they can carry out their mission according to their deeply held religious beliefs and convictions.

It’s crucial for church leaders to understand their legal rights, which is why ADF recently released a guide for church leaders to help them better understand this important, longstanding legal doctrine.

According to the church autonomy doctrine—which has been expanded, refined, and clarified over the years—there are four key areas where the government has no right to interfere. These include:

1. Issues of doctrine .

Places of worship can determine for themselves what they believe and how they apply those beliefs. The government does not have a right to get involved in these matters.

2. Determination of church polity.

This means churches can determine how they are governed and structured as an organization. The government is absolutely prohibited from interfering in this area.

3. Relationships with ministers.

The church autonomy doctrine protects a house of worship’s ability to select, credential, promote, discipline, and appoint ministers (or any teachers and leaders of the faith). Churches have the right not only to hire or fire their own ministers, but also to determine the employment policies their ministers must abide by. All of this is done without interference from the government.

4. Affiliation with church members.

This means the government can’t dictate what church membership entails. Houses of worship have the freedom to determine how one can become a member, the standards members will be held to, and how members will be disciplined.

It's apparent that church autonomy is vitally important for multiple reasons, but most of all because it secures freedom: freedom for churches to define for themselves what they believe, how they’ll be organized, who they hire, and how to best engage with their congregations. When there’s freedom in these matters, the Church—and the Gospel it promotes and preaches—has a chance to thrive and transform lives.

And that is something we can all support.

Get additional details on church autonomy, real-life stories about what its protections look like, and best practices to help clarify it for your church.

LEARN MORE


Scott Blakeman

Scott Blakeman

Content Creator, Church & Ministry Alliance

Prior to joining ADF, Scott served as a Speechwriter at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.


Church
How Houston Pastors Successfully Stood Up for Their Constitutional Rights

Imagine if you had escaped government oppression in search of freedom and safety for your family in a new country—only to be greeted yet again with the government treading on Constitutional rights.

Masked kid
New Hampshire Makes it Clear: A Pandemic is No Excuse to Trample Religious Freedom

As pandemic restrictions have begun to ease over the last few months, churches and religious organizations have started to ask: If this happens again, how can we ensure that religious freedom is protected?

The Smiths of Cedar Park Church
9th Circuit Sides With Seattle-Based Church Forced to Defend Pro-Life Views in Court

Cedar Park Church outside of Seattle, Washington is well-known for its commitment to the belief that all human life is precious and worth protecting.