BLOGGeorge Will: Vanderbilt Violates Religious Groups' Right to Association

By Jordan Lorence Posted on: | November 08, 2011

Influential columnist George F. Will wrote a column last week criticizing Vanderbilt University's decision to force student-led religious groups on campus to accept nonbelievers as members in order to stay meeting on campus.  His insightful opinions piece explains why the Constitution forbids such actions by public universities, and why it is unwise for private universities, like Vanderbilt, to pursue such ill-conceived policies:

Illustrating an intellectual confusion common on campuses, Vanderbilt University says: To ensure “diversity of thought and opinion” we require certain student groups, including five religious ones, to conform to the university’s policy that forbids the groups from protecting their characteristics that contribute to diversity.

Although a private university is under no obligation to obey the Constitution ( because the Constitution restrains only governmental power), Vanderbilt should take a lead in building diversity in the marketplace of ideas by allowing religious groups to require that their members and officers to agree with the beliefs and advocacy of the organization.  That is what most other campus groups regularly do at Vanderbilt and elsewhere.  Why should only religious groups be forced to accept people who disagree with the group's beliefs?

_____________________
Join the conversation Facebook.com/SpeakUpU
Sound off below – Leave a comment!

Jordan Lorence

Senior Counsel

Jordan Lorence, Esq., serves as senior counsel with Alliance Defending Freedom.

More from ADF View All

3 Questions with the Attorney Who Argued Trinity Lutheran before the Supreme Court Last Week

Religious Freedom

3 Questions with the Attorney Who Argued Trinity Lutheran before the Supreme Court Last Week

Here’s what ADF Senior Counsel David Cortman had to say about the oral argume...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 04/25/2017 18:00:00 Read More

Freedom For All: Why Two Artists’ Stand Should Matter to Everyone

Religious Freedom

Freedom For All: Why Two Artists’ Stand Should Matter to Everyone

If you asked Joanna Duka two years ago what she thought her biggest challenge...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 03/09/2017 17:30:00 Read More

Abortion Industry’s Interests Should Never Outweigh Public Concerns or First Amendment Rights

Sanctity of Life

Abortion Industry’s Interests Should Never Outweigh Public Concerns or First Amendment Rights

Two years after the National Abortion Federation filed a lawsuit against CMP,...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 04/21/2017 21:11:05 Read More

This Is What Happens When the American Bar Association Tries to Censor Attorney Speech

Culture

This Is What Happens When the American Bar Association Tries to Censor Attorney Speech

Facing increasing opposition to its new speech code rule, the American Bar As...

Mr. Funny | Words | Author | I'm the icon | www | 04/24/2017 22:00:00 Read More